Saturday, 13 June 2009

Poll: Ibrahimovic or Ribery

46 comments:

pep said...

You can vote until Monday morning. Multiple votes are not counted.

MohamedH said...

I voted for Ibra... i think ibra is the best option, since he wants to come to barca, while ribery seems to prefer madrid... They are both world class in their position...
IN: Ibra - Zhirkov - Henrique - Felipe
OUT: Sylvinho - Caceres - Eto'o

I think these minor adjustments are sufficient for another succefull season...

fcbee said...

Ribery seems more willing to come, he would already have a pre-agreement. It's just Zidane who's messing things up. Zlatan will just go the highest bidder.

deco said...

Priority should be someone to replace Eto'o.
Because it seems he doesn't want to renew. Otherwise we miss a lot of money.

Zlatan would be the best option,(villa to real ???),Aguero(could central and left= 2 maradonna in 1 team)
We need no header like Dzeko for god sakes, we are barcelona not a premier leage team.

A left winger is not that urgent. Next year we got Henry and Iniesta,Gai.
We could sign a left winger next year.

FC BARCA said...

Ribery should be Barça's highest priority. But Bayern want way too much for him and Zlatan is overrated in my opinion.

deco said...

Zlatan is even better than eto'o
He not only stong, big and fast.
He can do magic with his feet.

If Guardiola want messi to play a while in the centre, Zlatan can create danger from the wing. Not only playing their like Eto'o does

wolfie said...

A top winger is an absolute priority. We only have Messi and Ineista who really can make the difference there and both aren't even real wingers (and Iniesta could also be needed in midfield). Both are injury-prone too, so no winger is a huge risk. Henry had a great season but he's getting old and won't repeat that so Ribery can give both Henry and Messi time to rest. He's also hungry as hell and a good guy, so he won't cause problems.

Anonymous said...

If we would have bought Ribery from Marseille in 2007, we could have had both... I would say Ribery because he can bring more speed and movement on the wings, which is what we need against smaller teams, excellent dribbler too so good in one-on-one. I think Ibra would have a hard time adapting to the 4-3-3.

Anonymous said...

deco

I think you have to wait a little while to consider Gai. Gai wasn't even good on the B team this year. We really do need a winger. Ibrahimovic would only replace Etoo.

Marc4barca said...

everyone knows who i voted for.

Amir said...

i know Marc4barca it's the same as me!:D

Mike said...

Why not Benayoun instead? We can't afford these players.

ej said...

pep


what about a poll later for man of the season/year

i think there will be some suprises

FC BARCA said...

The reality is if Inter wants €70 mil for Zlatan, Barça will never get him. And the same goes for Ribery, they are both greatly overpriced.

Iason said...

Man, I want Ribery and I think he is a far better player than Zlatan and I know that we need a LW but Zlatan in Barca just looks so good. The connection he would have with Iniesta, Messi and Xavi seems to be there already and not to mention the goals he would score from Alves' crosses. Plus, we need more tall players. But I don't agree with Deco, Zlatan isn't that fat at all.

Marws said...

Everyone is overpriced after Reals crazy bids :(

Finaly a poll on who we should buy :D Ribery seems too be winning. I hope Eto'o signs a new contract that isn't too expensive for the club. In that case lets go for Ribery. Otherwise we need to sell Eto'o, and buy a new CF. Everything but the price is perfect about Ibra.

Iason said...

Sorry, not far better, only a tiny bit better is what I meant to say.

Culer_Than_Thou said...

Ignore reality for a while bro... pep's given us a hypothetical situation.
I'd love to have Ribery... but to break the bus that we'll face at Anfield, Old Trafford, Stamford Bridge etc... Ibrahimovic is a must.
Dani's crosses + Xavi's thru balls + Messi & Iniesta's footwaork + Ibracadabra = BusBreaker.
Though i admit... Ribery would fit into Barca effortlessly too.

Marc4barca said...

http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.sport.es&hl=es&ie=UTF-8&sl=es&tl=en - the other messi.

FCB said...

I know that barca won't spend much money but realy we need both of them, couse Henry is getting old and we don't know if Eto'o will renew his contract.
Think about it...Ribery-Zlatan-Messi.
To good to be true aint it???

Mike said...

Perhaps we can extort cska to give us zhirkov? do you think we can get zhirkov for 20m euros if we put extreme pressure on cska and the player whose favorite team is barcelona?

Mike said...

FCB: don't you think this looks better:

-Zhirkov-Dzeko-Messi

we get 2 super players for the price of one of zlatan's feet!

ej said...

i would like ibery - ibra - messi

much more




maybe nie will help us , since addidas helped rm nike may cnsider paying pat of ribery deal :

ribery and barca works with nike
bayern with addidas.

and nike may just want to show addidas that they can do the same...

just hoping ...

Mike said...

I think it is quite clear that Zhirkov is superior to Ribery, he is the amazing this Russian, much better than Arshavin too.

Anonymous said...

Kaka and Ronaldo

Barca nerd-fan said...

If Eto'o leaves, we either get Villa as straight replacement or play Henry up front and get Ribery and Dzeko, Henry still got it... the pace, control, skill, finish. No Ibra because he would be too expensive.

FCB said...

Zhirkov is good, but i don't know about Dzeko. I think hes that kind of striker thats preform good in smaller teams like Zigic, Forlan, Gilardino and Berbatov. I don't think he would play like he do know if he played for Barca because of all the pressure. Well thats what i think anyway.

FCB said...

Plus i'm from Sweden so I'd rather se Zlatan wearing the blaugrana shirt than Dzeko :P

ej said...

!!!!!!!!!IMPORTANT!!!!!!!!!!


chelsea offer barca melouda !!

http://goal.com/en/news/12/spain/2009/06/13/1323353/chelsea-offer-malouda-to-barcelona-report


he is not bad and i guess since they offer him we can get him for 15 M !!!

i say go for it

Anonymous said...

malouda is nothing

ej said...

ribery is ofc better but malouda cost us 15 M ribey 50 ... so moe than 3 times

Don Luis said...

i voted for Ribery.

Imagine Messi and Ribery at the wings..

Anonymous said...

none! i respect both of them, but i think they are not meant for barca, especially Ibra(with his attitude)...I think David Silva is better. He's younger, he don't have to learn how to speak spanish(of course, he's spanish), and he already know the way Xavi-Iniesta plays in the national squad. But if Pep is very sure if Gai is the next big think, then we should sign Ribery, so Gai could watch and learn from him

R10FCB said...

i voted for ribery because we need a quality left winger. henry did great this season but its not his natural position and he plays so much better in cf anyway. i use to say go for ibra to replace eto'o but now im more of a higuain fan. the guys great, young and would probably play very well with messi, some might call me crazy for this but in my opinion he is better than aguero.

Messi108 said...

Ribery should be Barça's highest priority !
Ribery-Eto'o( Henry/Bojan )-Messi

Best attack force in Europe !
Malouda is a waste. Cant imagine Barca signing the waste winger :(
Chelsea are giving him away so that they can sign the better that is Ribery. They know that with Bara in the game , they cant sign Ribery.

Anurag said...

people, people, ribery is directly in line with barca's philosophy. i really love the way he plays. and anyways, we dont have the strongest left flank in world football, you know. ribery on LW and maybe maxwell or filipe on LB, would be deadly.

ibrahimovich is as i said not my choice for this great club at ALL.

Anonymous said...

Its no question- Ribery is made for Barca in every way. I pray he comes in. Also if Eto'o leaves the ideal addition has to be David Villa. Ibra is not Barca standard as a footballing mind. He is talented but not what we need...

Anonymous said...

priority is a striker...laporta & moretti didn't meet up last week just to shoot the shit. eto'o, txiki, pep, & joan all know he's gone next year.

ibra has played in a 4-3-3 w/ajax, played brilliantly w/juvenuts when he had the chance, & has had to carry inter for the past 3 seasons. he's the ideal tall striker guardiola's been looking for. eto'o + 20-25 mil(no maxwell) should seal the deal.

henry, iniesta, bojan, hleb, & gai can all play on the lw so ribery, although very talented, would be more of a luxury than a necessity.

supposing barca only had 30 million to spend, the other 10 mil would go to signing a sylvinho replacement, i.e. filipe. although for my money i'd much rather sell hleb + dudjohnsen & spend 20 mil on david silva for the wing.

silva-ibra-messi

i'd have henrique, a healthy milito, or muniesa play second fiddle to abidal. buy back crosas for 2 mil and promote thiago as back up for xavi & iniesta, respectively.

Anonymous said...

^^^
thebackseatstrangler

NouBarca said...

I love the results so far.

barcezgi said...

i voted ribery.messi and ribery on the wings would be perfect.

Ono said...

None.
Neither Ibra nor Ribery are better then what we have.

ba-beka said...

Zlatan case is done , he is Barca player on the next season , we have to work now on Ribery which i believe it's done to .
Visca Barca

Iason said...

Actually, I change my mind. I want Ribery. Imagine the opposition having to double mark Messi, Ribery, Iniesta, and Xavi! That would only leave two players to cover Eto'o, Alves and then another attacking LB. That would be great. Buy Philip Lahm or Gael Clichy right now!

Maxi said...

im really undecided. if we got ribery (whom i prefer) what about a striker, whereas if we get ibra and not ribery that still leaves us with Silva who i think would be perfect for us.

Anonymous said...

FUNNY
Barca vs. RM

The War

http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.sport.es&hl=es&ie=UTF-8&sl=es&tl=en

Custom Search
 
Custom Search