Valdés 6___6___6___7
Alves 6___6,5___7___6,5
Piqué 6___8,5___8___7
Márquez 6___7,5___5___6,5
Puyol 7___7___7___6,5
Xavi 8___8,5___8___8
Keita 6___7,5___6___6
Iniesta 7___8___8___6,5
Messi 6___8,5___5___6,5
Eto'o 6___7,5___8___6
Henry 7___9___8___6,5
Touré 4___6___7___5,5
Pedro 5___6___4___6
Sylvinho 5___6___3___5,5
(sport-goal-offside-oleole)
If you have seen the match, you can give your own points. If you know other papers or sites that give points, you can let me know. See previous points here.
Wednesday, 17 September 2008
The Points: Sporting
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Posts
16 comments:
Man of the match: Guardiola, for taking Abidal out!
(player,comment,rating)
Valdes = Solid 7
Pique = Good 7
Marquez = Acceptable 7.5
Puyol > Abidal 6.5
Alves = Improved 7.5
Xavi = Master 8
Iniesta = Great 8
Keita > Toure 8
Messi = Bad luck 6.5
Eto'o = Good 7
Henry = Improved 7
Toure = Bench 6
Pedro = Bench 6
Sylvinho = N/A
6__6
how are you giving points..
These points are taking from other sites and blogs, Anony. Guess they all have their own criteria.
i dont start at 0 or 10. A player for me starts in the mid which would be five, and depending on their performance they either gain or lose points.
If i wouldve started at 0, then Pedro and Toure wouldve scored a 0 or a 1 and thats not a fair rating for anyone. In my book if you get anywhere from 1-3 you had an AWEFULL game. And i very rarely give a 3 or a 2. So thats my system.
@ memo. Y would you give Henry and Eto same points? Was there perfomance the same? If you was Barca caoch am sure you would have a few SARCRED COWS. U can say all u like about Abidal, he gets the stick for the goal we concede in 0-1 loss but you would say Eto, Bojan, Iniesta, Messi really tried but was unlucky to convert one of our 20 chances in the same 0-1 loss.. How many chance does Messi, Eto and co need to score a frikking goal? lets be fair in our judgements
I think it doesn't only depend on goals, Eto'o was working really hard (like he usually does) and that's probably what Guardiola asked him to do.
And he did score. Ok, it's "only" a penalty but he caused it too. Eto'o is admitting he's not at his best yet, but growing towards his top again. Let's hope we'll see the real goalscoring Eto'o soon. Although we already saw him in pre-season.
@ Noubarca
You know what when you have done as much for the club as Eto'o and Messi have, you EARN that kind of respect. What has Abidal done for us? I'll tell you what, hes done SHIT for this team! You have to earn the respect you get to be allowed bad performances. And so far Abidal has been in the minus column of this since he got here.
And as far as Eto'o and Henry, they both had good games as far as im concerned. Eto'o scored, but it was a PK and he did his job. Henry had a few good shots on goal. He didnt stink it up like he has in the past.
You wanna give your own rating go ahead. I doubt they will be the same as mine, so quit crying and let us all know how you saw it.
hey buddy.. I DNOT CRY... i talk sense.. I am matured enough to make constuctive citisism.
@ Noubarca
You question my ratings, but i fail to see yours. Did you even watch the game?
you are sounding very petty now. But to answer you, I watched it my friend; on Skysports 2.channel 402. lol.. u are a laughing stock.. didnt u say sell Yaya? LOL.......
No need to get personal, guys. Stick to the game.
my sincere apologies to Pep and all other service users/supporters for my comments. I have learnt how to deal with situations and people. I am really sorry!
Post a Comment