This is the final result of this blog's Is Seydou Keita a good transfer? poll:
27% ... 8
25% ... 7
16% ... 10
11% ... 9
6% ... 6
6% ... 5
5% ... Don't know
2% ... 4
1% ... 3
1% ... 0
1% ... 1
1% ... 2
Average score: 7.61
Saturday, 23 August 2008
Poll result - Rating the new guys: Keita
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Posts
10 comments:
Average score = average of all the points given (the "don't know" votes aren't counted here).
Tomorrow we'll have the same poll on our second signing: Gerard Piqué.
He shouldn't get rated less than 7.
look diferent people judje with diferent aspects.
i judje by the games i seen him last season and the preseason with us
in terms of footballing where messi gets a 10 keita gets a 2 but in terms of midfield player he gets a 4 for me ,i rate xavi a solid 10 and yaya an 8 ,keita isnt anywere near those 2 to get 7+.
on the other hand you have some people who say he is a barca player lets give him a 10 ,and you may have a real madrid fanboy and put a 0.
i thought he would get a rate near 6 but it seems there are more people that put blindly high numbers without having watched the preseason or know the player.
anyway i think tomorrow pique will see more love caue he has done awesome preseason and he was bought very cheap,also a talent for the future.
keep up the good work pep.awesome blog
"on the other hand you have some people who say he is a barca player lets give him a 10 ,and you may have a real madrid fanboy and put a 0.
i thought he would get a rate near 6 but it seems there are more people that put blindly high numbers without having watched the preseason or know the player."
People aren't automatically wrong just 'cause they don't agree with what you think.
I believe in Keita.
well thats a very realistic rating he got for what i have "seen in his last year performance and preseason" florentina game for example?
"i thought he would get a rate near 6 but it seems there are more people that put blindly high numbers without having watched the preseason or know the player."
skanjos I am one of the blinds:)
if you think he deserves a 10 then its ok ,but i think a 10% will always vote 10 in every player so that the rating will go high thats what i say.
its not bad to believe in keita ,but another think is believing in him and another thinking he is the best in the position we could get cause thats what a 10 means to me,and to me he is not the best MC we could get.
(many think he is a DM,well he is not he is an MC he cant play the yaya spot,which even xavi can play and that is a minus too)
if you think keita deserves a 10 what would you give world class MC players or young talented MC if we got them?example essien/veloso/van der vaart/fabregas/moutinho
essien:u cant get.
veloso:give me his CV.
van der vaart:we have much better (technical than him (xavi&iniesta) while is physics r nothing to be compared to keita.
fabregas:again he offer the same role as xavi&iniesta and u cant get him for cheap.
moutinho:same thing as above.
Dear kieta is not a yaya for sure, and thats a good thing, tacticaly he complete the trio with xavi and yaya, because he is someone in between, u got him for 15 M add strength, shooting power,tactical varestility and leadership in midfield.
saying that Xavi can play yaya role is an expiring myth...lot of people thought so but i thought after the past seasons where xavi played as DM and team got troubles, and after xavi played in a more offensive role and proved excilance i thought no one would mention this again.No xavi is a waste of a great talent to be invested in this position.keita is a must, and he is the only one who have the right atribute for that role(whom u can get for 15 M).unless if u can get essien for that.
u evaluate a transaction based on the options available, and if the options available are the ones u mentioned (regarding attributes,risk,experience&price)then i will give kieta a 12.
essien- we could get for 25mill and is a powerhouse type
veloso- is an extraordinary young dm that is a beast ,very hardworking with exelent passes (direct and long) also very highly teq gifted player,also a player we could get
van der vaart-is a very creative player and plays best at amc(not kind the powerhouse like you mention but i rate him higher than keita as an MC)
fabregas- he is nothing like iniesta ,has some aspects of his game similar to xavi but has more physical build is more creative and the best midfielder out there
moutinho- is like deco a clear creative player that is hard worker and does the foul when its needed
so we have yaya and marquez for stregth in the team/yaya and xavi for mid range shooting/alot of players for tactical versatility/and xavi for leadership in the middle(not that keita is that kind of a player but lets play a little)
barca can sign any player,but we dont give away money ,i would love our club to go and sign fabregas for 35-40mill but thats not gonna happen because we are cheap ,we always were.also dont give me that crap about us not having money,this summer we had alot of money from transfers out also alot of money from the champions league,yet the only big price player we have signed is dani alves,we are like milan we think that with our big name we can atract players and they will ask the club to lower the fee(like we are doing with hernanes/arshavin cases)
every player is on the market for the right price and i prefer a 30million bid for essien that a 15million for keita anytime.
skanjos give me a break man...essien for 25 M?where do u love?he was bought for more than that and he succeeded in Chelsea being the most important piece in their puzzle and they r not a selling team...25 M?sorry my friend thats a silly naive remark:)
veloso is a player i know and follow,he is promising but unproved on highst level, but if he is half what u said he wouldnt find it that hard to move (lot of teams were initialy interested in him like milan,but for the RIGHT price) right?
van der vaart is good, but he is a totaly defferent player that kieta, so its wrong to say get this instead of that, its like saying "get Torres he is better than Vidic" u simply cant do that because they dont play same role on the field, if u know tactical aspects of the game.having iniesta and xavi (then hleb)means no place for vander vart.(by the way lets c how he perform for real,u will be shocked..mark my words)
fabregas will never play behind Xavi or as a low CM anymore...watch more games for arsenal may be u will understand what that mean, so again not a kieta,regardless of the fact that u cant get him this season "cant mean defenitly CAN NOT).
moutinho is not a deco and dont have the physical presence that pep needed for his midfield thru getting keita, Barca learned a good lesson after playing against english teams in CL,obviously u didnt.
essien and fabri, u can get that easy on "football management"the game on pc, but not in real life so...join us in real world.
"where do u live", not where do u love :)
Post a Comment